September 29th 2012

  Buy Issue 2885

Articles from this issue:

NATIONAL AFFAIRS: Violent Islamism erupts on the streets of Sydney

FOREIGN AFFAIRS: Indonesia, Australia's increasingly intolerant ally

EDITORIAL: Gillard to cut defence as global tensions mount

CANBERRA OBSERVED: Can Gillard poll upswing save Labor from wipe-out?

FOREIGN INVESTMENT: Cubbie Station sale exposes weak foreign ownership rules

NATIONAL AFFAIRS: Labor and Coalition now eager to court the DLP

CONSTRUCTION: Grocon dispute points to return of the BLF

ECONOMIC AFFAIRS: What is productivity and why is it important?

UNITED KINGDOM: Nigel Farage, scourge of Europe's political elites

CULTURE AND CIVILISATION: Education wars: the battle for our children

HUMAN RIGHTS: China announces end to forced abortions

EUTHANASIA: Nitschke offers "undetectable" death by suffocation

HEALTH: Legalising illicit drugs will inflict greater harm


CINEMA: The terrifying truth of the Noble Savage

BOOK REVIEW The original "Red Tory"

BOOK REVIEW Battle of wits in Nazi-occupied Rome

Books promotion page

Indonesia, Australia's increasingly intolerant ally

by Adrian Morgan

News Weekly, September 29, 2012

On Monday, August 27, two Shia Muslims were hacked to death and 39 houses were burned in Sampang, East Java.[1] This is just the latest of a series of sectarian killings carried out by radical Sunni Muslims in Indonesia. Over the past decade, Islamism has spread with little opposition from the government, and attacks upon minorities have escalated.

In May 1998, Suharto resigned after 31 years as president. Within seven months of his departure from office, Islamists burned churches in Poso, Central Sulawesi, the beginnings of an inter-religious conflict that soon spread to the Moluccan Islands in January 1999.

FPI founder Muhammad Rizieq Syihab

FPI founder Muhammad Rizieq Syihab 

In Ambon, the conflict between Muslims and Christians escalated in mid-2000, when 2,000 jihadist fighters from Laskar Jihad were sent from Java to the region.[2] Massacres took place, particularly in the village of Soya in Ambon, where even children were attacked with machetes.

According to the Sydney Morning Herald (January 27, 2001), on six of the Moluccan Islands, 3,928 Christians were forced to convert to Islam. The conversions involved forced circumcisions, including female genital mutilation (FGM). Females forced to be “circumcised” included pregnant women, septuagenarians and babies.

Bizarrely, the founder and leader of Laskar Jihad, Ja’far Umar Thalib, was subsequently cleared of inciting religious violence.[3] Thalib reputedly had support from mainstream politicians, including Hamzah Haz,[4] who was Indonesia’s vice-president from 2001 until 2004.

Though Laskar Jihad was officially disbanded, the Front Pembela Islam (FPI), founded in 1998 by Saudi-educated Muhammad Rizieq Syihab, has also enjoyed support from the army and police, with the latter said to have funded the group.[5]

The FPI has enacted vigilante attacks upon bars, threatened aid workers after the 2004 tsunami, and has mobilised vigilantes to pressure judges in court cases, to force the closure of nudity-free Playboy magazine, and to attack the American Embassy in Jakarta during the Danish cartoon crisis. In Jakarta, a local group called the Betawi Brotherhood Forum (Forum Betawi Rempug or FBR) has acted in similar fashion.

More than 17,500 islands comprise Indonesia’s archipelago, encompassing various faiths and languages. The 1945 constitution contains the Pancasila (“five precepts”) doctrine, which guarantees pluralism and religious freedom. Politicians and clerical leaders, who are mostly Muslim and based on Java, are testing Indonesia’s reputed “tolerance”.

There are an estimated 50,000 to 80,000 Ahmadiyah Muslims in Indonesia, though these are regarded by hardliners as heretics. On July 27, 2005, a body of Islamic clerics (the MUI) declared a fatwa against pluralism. Subsequently, supporters of pluralism were threatened, and in Sukadana, West Java, a mob attacked an Ahmadiyah community, burning houses and mosques.[6] In Lombok, an island near Bali, Ahmadiyah have been persecuted. The FPI are involved in such attacks.[7]

On June 9, 2008, bowing to pressure from Islamists, including the FPI and the “moderate” Muhammadiyah group, the government of Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono passed a decree ordering that Ahmadiyah who proselytise can be jailed for five years for blasphemy.[8] With their rights limited, attacks have increased. In February 2011, a 1,000-strong mob attacked Ahmadiyah in West Java. Three Ahmadiyah were stripped naked and beaten to death while police stood by.[9]

Since 1999, sharia bylaws have also eroded the Pancasila principles. In 2006, the Jakarta Post noted that implementation of sharia bylaws in various regencies was violating the constitution.[10]

Padang municipal administration, for example, had introduced demeaning regulations for all schoolgirls, including non-Muslims, forcing them to wear Muslim head coverings. In South Sulawesi, several administrative regions make it compulsory for female civil servants to wear Islamic dress. All government employees there must be able to read and write Arabic.[12] In April this year, a lecturer at Kalijaga State Islamic University in Yoghyakarta warned that these sharia bylaws could be a “time-bomb” and trigger social conflict.[12]

Without full support for pluralism, Indonesia could split apart, and the ramifications for Australia of such a populous nation fragmenting could be horrendous. Either Australia could be drawn in to resolve conflict, as in East Timor, or it could be faced with the consequences of coping with floods of refugees.

Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono is an ally of Australia. Failure to pressure his government to support its minorities will not be in anyone’s best interests, including Australian investors.

Through the Saudi-dominated Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), there are forces all too ready to encourage Indonesia to abandon pluralism and religious tolerance altogether. Australia cannot afford to have its ally and neighbour turning into a totalitarian theocracy.

Adrian Morgan has written for the UK Guardian and New Scientist and is a former Fellow of the Royal Anthropological Society. He hosts a weekly internet radio show called Global Security Matters.


[1] Agence France Presse, “Indonesia Muslim mob kills two, burns houses”, Himalayan Times (Kathmandu, Nepal), August 27, 2012.

[2] Jonathan Head, “Analysis: Behind the Moluccan violence”, BBC News (World Edition), July 2, 2000.

[3] “Profile: Jafar Umar Thalib”, BBC News (World Edition), January 30, 2003.

[4] “Ja’far Umar Thalib (Indonesian)” entry in Wikipedia.

[5] Bagus B.T. Saragih, “WikiLeaks: National police funded FPI hard-liners”, Jakarta Post, September 5, 2011.

[6] Tim Johnston, “Minority mosques in Indonesia attacked by mob”, (Religious persecution of Ahmadiyya Muslim community), September 21, 2005.

[7] Adrian Morgan, “Indonesia — a civil war between Islamists and moderates? Part one of two”, (Religious persecution of Ahmadiyya Muslim community), June 9, 2008.

[8] Geoff Thompson, “Jakarta walks a line over Islamist demands”, ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation), June 10, 2008.

[9] “Indonesia pressured over Ahmadiyah Muslim sect killings”, BBC News (Asia-Pacific), February 8, 2011.

[10] Ridwan Max Sijabat, “Sharia-based bylaws violate Constitution”, Jakarta Post, May 4, 2006.

[11] Adrian Morgan, “Indonesia — exchanging pluralism for an Islamist state”, Western Resistance, June 9, 2006.

[12] Bambang Muryanto, “Sharia bylaws ‘time bomb’”, Jakarta Post, April 20, 2012.


Join our mailing list

Your cart has 0 items

Subscribe to NewsWeekly

Research Papers


Trending articles

NATIONAL AFFAIRS What's behind the Australian Liberty Alliance?

SOCIETY Fatherlessness linked to increased risk of child abuse

SOCIETY Homosexual 'marriage'? First, listen to the children

QUEENSLAND STATE ELECTION Governments want belt-tightening, but voters want jobs

QUEENSLAND STATE ELECTION Choice facing Queensland voters on January 31

GREAT THINKERS What Edmund Burke has to say to the modern world

SOCIETY Joblessness drives the retreat from marriage

News and views from around the world

Jack Straw and Sir Malcolm Rifkind in latest 'cash for access' scandal (UK Telegraph)

The real mind-blowing terror threat in our midst is cannabis (Peter Hitchens)

Canada's activist Supreme Court legalises 'assisted death' (Andrew Coyne, National Post)

China has no plans to suspend forced and sex-selection abortions

Fifty shades of shame – the evolution of pornography (Albert Mohler)

NYT finds New Yorkers love micro-apartments

Posh-bashing and the University of Oiks (Gabriel Hershman)

Degree in hand, millennials move home after university

It's 'bad etiquette' to thank veterans for their service: New York Times

Churchill’s funeral, 50 years on (The Imaginative Conservative)

© Copyright 2011
Last Modified:
September 24, 2014, 12:53 pm